- Malik Nabers is primed for an additional target-filled season: The Giants will feed Nabers as soon as once more this season, which is certain to result in vital fantasy manufacturing as he enters Year 2.
- Amon-Ra St. Brown has been an image of high-end consistency: St. Brown’s expertise and offensive state of affairs have led to back-to-back PPR WR3 seasons, and he ought to be in for an additional large yr in 2025.
- Subscribe to PFF+: Get entry to participant grades, PFF Premium Stats, fantasy soccer rankings, the entire PFF fantasy draft analysis instruments and extra!
This fantasy soccer article collection breaks down the hardest draft-day selections going through fantasy managers, utilizing Underdog’s common draft place (ADP) as a information. Each installment compares equally ranked gamers on the similar place, utilizing key stats from earlier seasons and contextual components — together with workforce state of affairs — to establish the higher decide.
Today’s matchup options New York Giants extensive receiver Malik Nabers and Detroit Lions extensive receiver Amon-Ra St. Brown, two gamers going close to the tip of the primary spherical in fantasy drafts. Which one provides the higher worth? Let’s break it down.
MALIK NABERS (WR5) vs. AMON-RA ST. BROWN (WR6)
Nabers burst onto the scene in his rookie yr, serving as the focus of a Giants offense that leaned closely on him from the beginning. He completed second within the NFL with 165 targets throughout simply 15 video games and led all rookie extensive receivers with an 87.1 receiving grade in 2024. Nabers recorded 5 top-10 weekly finishes and ended the season because the PPR WR6.
In distinction, St. Brown operated in a extra balanced Lions passing assault that didn’t depend on him as singularly, because of a deeper supporting solid. Still, he remained a central determine, rating top-10 in targets (138) and top-five in receiving yards (1,263). He posted six top-10 weekly finishes, together with two weeks as the general PPR WR1.
INVOLVEMENT IN THE OFFENSE
Nabers ranked second amongst 130 qualifying extensive receivers in goal charge, trailing solely Puka Nacua (37.0%). His utilization as a main learn was equally notable, as he completed second within the NFL with 133 first-read targets. He additionally led the league with 11.0 targets per recreation as a rookie. Given New York’s quiet offseason by way of pass-catching additions, Nabers is poised to stay one of many league’s most closely focused gamers in 2025.
St. Brown, alternatively, has thrived in a secure and environment friendly Detroit offense, producing back-to-back WR3 finishes in PPR codecs and 4 straight top-eight seasons general. The Lions haven’t needed to funnel targets to him the way in which the Giants do with Nabers, which can cap his general quantity. Still, St. Brown persistently capitalizes on his alternatives and stays probably the most environment friendly high-usage extensive receivers within the league.
PRODUCTION AND PERFORMANCE
St. Brown’s expertise, expertise, and match inside Detroit’s offense have allowed him to flourish as one of many league’s high extensive receivers. Coming out of 2024, he outperformed Nabers in a number of key classes — a end result to be anticipated when evaluating a longtime star to a rookie. Still, Nabers seems poised to shut that hole rapidly, as his rookie-year metrics already place him in elite firm.
Efficiency stays a serious power for St. Brown. He ranked twelfth in yards per route run and completed top-five in PFF receiving grade. While he might not persistently outpace Nabers in weekly goal quantity, he advantages from working in a well-rounded offense that forestalls defenses from locking in on him. That benefit ought to proceed to create area and alternatives for St. Brown to supply WR1-level numbers.
HIGH-VALUE TARGET INVOLVEMENT
St. Brown holds one other edge over Nabers in relation to high-value scoring alternatives. The Lions led the league with 227 offensive snaps within the crimson zone final season, whereas the Giants ranked thirty first with simply 121. As a end result, St. Brown ran 103 red-zone routes — practically double Nabers’ 54 — and turned these into 31 targets, 24 receptions, and 9 touchdowns.
Nabers was a transparent red-zone focus for the Giants, however the offense’s general inefficiency restricted his alternatives. That dynamic might not shift dramatically in 2025, although the addition of Russell Wilson brings some hope. Wilson helped the Steelers generate 115 red-zone performs (tied for seventh) after taking on as starter. If he can elevate the Giants’ scoring possibilities, Nabers stands to learn most and will simply construct on his 14 red-zone targets, six catches, and three touchdowns from final season.
TEAM PASSING AND QUARTERBACK SITUATION
Russell Wilson is not the quarterback he as soon as was, as mirrored by his 74.1 passing grade over the previous three seasons — rating simply twenty first out of 28 qualifying quarterbacks. In distinction, Jared Goff has earned a top-10 passing grade since 2022, main a Lions offense that persistently carried out at the next degree regardless of a conservative method. Detroit ranked twenty ninth in cross charge final season, an element that would restrict St. Brown’s ceiling, particularly with the workforce unlikely to deviate a lot from Dan Campbell’s established offensive philosophy.
Wilson enters 2025 in a totally new atmosphere below head coach Brian Daboll, whose offenses have ranked top-10 in cross charge every of the previous two seasons. While a few of that quantity is tied to the Giants typically enjoying from behind, it’s honest to count on one other pass-heavy method — even when the workforce doesn’t take a large leap ahead.
That projected quantity is a key edge for Nabers. He might not have the quarterback benefit, however few gamers within the league are prone to see extra complete targets. If Wilson can ship the ball extra precisely than Nabers skilled in 2024, that alone might give the second-year wideout the sting over St. Brown in fantasy worth for 2025.
POTENTIAL 2025 TARGET COMPETITION
Wan’Dale Robinson stood out in goal charge final season, largely as a consequence of his quarterback-friendly position as a low common depth of goal (ADoT) and screen-game choice. He totaled 132 targets (14th amongst extensive receivers) whereas working with the third-lowest ADoT on the place (5.1 yards). Robinson will stay a key a part of the offense, however his position is distinct from Nabers’ and shouldn’t be considered as a risk to Nabers’ quantity or upside in 2025. Robinson completed because the PPR WR37, whereas Nabers, regardless of lacking two video games, ended the yr because the WR6.
St. Brown faces stiffer competitors for targets. Sam LaPorta emerged as probably the most closely focused tight ends within the league, particularly within the crimson zone, the place he ranked top-five on the place with 18 targets. Both LaPorta (9) and Jameson Williams (14) noticed extra deep targets (20-plus yards) than St. Brown (seven) in 2024, barely capping his entry to high-value alternatives. By comparability, Nabers noticed 29 such targets — greater than double that of any Lions pass-catcher.
Still, St. Brown’s elite manufacturing stands out. Despite the competitors, he completed because the WR3 in PPR codecs final season, whereas Williams completed because the WR23 and LaPorta because the TE7. That degree of output underscores St. Brown’s capability to thrive even in a crowded offense.