- Marvin Harrison Jr. upset in his rookie season: He was anticipated to complete as a top-20 fantasy broad receiver, however as a substitute completed at WR30.
- J.J. McCarthy is ready up for achievement: The Minnesota Vikings teaching workers, talent gamers led by Justin Jefferson, and the offensive line ought to put McCarthy ready for achievement in his first season as an NFL starter.
- Subscribe to PFF+: Get entry to participant grades, PFF Premium Stats, fantasy soccer rankings, the entire PFF fantasy draft analysis instruments and extra!
Estimated studying time: 17 minutes
The 2024 NFL draft class has yielded a number of fantasy stars, as Jayden Daniels, Bucky Irving, Malik Nabers, Brian Thomas Jr., Ladd McConkey, and Brock Bowers are already thought of among the many greatest at their respective positions. However, there are nonetheless plenty of different gamers who might make strides this season, making them worthy of consideration at numerous factors of fantasy soccer drafts.
Here are 5 second-year gamers who didn’t totally stay as much as expectations as rookies however are price contemplating at their present ADP and even earlier.
The common draft place listed is from a consensus between ESPN, Sleeper and Yahoo! for the place the participant is picked on common in a 12-team, redraft league.
Last up to date: Thursday, July 3
WR Marvin Harrison Jr., Arizona Cardinals (ADP: 4.08)
Harrison was the fourth general decide within the 2024 draft, which was the very best any broad receiver had been picked since Amari Cooper within the 2015 draft. He was an instantaneous starter for the Arizona Cardinals with a whole lot of expectations. He performed not less than 80% of Arizona’s offensive snaps in most losses, however that might drop as little as 70% relying on how a lot the Cardinals had been successful by of their victories.
After a quiet debut, he confirmed a few of his promise by the remainder of September, totalling 14 receptions for 239 yards and 4 touchdowns in his following three video games. He handled a minor harm however confirmed his promise once more in Week 8, ending with six receptions for 111 yards and a landing. He adopted that up with seven consecutive video games beneath 60 receiving yards. Harrison completed 2024 on a excessive notice, accumulating 11 receptions for 159 yards and a landing over his closing two video games.
This left him thirtieth in whole fantasy factors regardless of not lacking a recreation. He solely had two video games as a top-12 fantasy broad receiver, and he ranked outdoors the highest 48 in over 40% of his video games. His PFF receiving grade was twenty ninth amongst broad receivers with not less than 200 routes run final season. His goal share was typically effective, as his 114 targets had been tied for the Nineteenth-most amongst broad receivers, however solely 69 of these targets had been catchable, rating Thirty seventh-most. His 45 uncatchable targets had been probably the most within the league, and his 39.5% uncatchable charge was the very best among the many 52 broad receivers with not less than 75 targets.
Harrison is not going to solely have the identical competitors for targets but additionally the identical offensive coordinator, quarterback, operating again room and many of the identical offensive line. The Cardinals haven’t run a whole lot of performs per recreation however have run the ball greater than most groups, which works somewhat bit in opposition to Harrison.
The greater drawback was his chemistry with Kyler Murray. Part of the problem is that Harrison has 23 targets when Murray was beneath stress, ending with a 17.4-yard common depth of goal, and solely 11 of these passes had been catchable. Lots of the issue was Murray’s chemistry with Harrison, resulting in awkward ball placement, or Harrison merely not being the place Murray thought he can be. Murray’s accuracy hasn’t typically been an issue, so this appears fixable. Head coach Jonathan Gannon stated he expects an enormous leap, and Murray has talked about enhancing their chemistry and timing.
Looking at historic information from the final decade, gamers with a 60.5% catchable goal charge one yr usually regress to the imply and have a 68.8% catchable goal the next yr. While that’s nonetheless under league common for broad receivers, that might be sufficient to maneuver him from WR30 to WR17. If you imagine Murray and Harrison can enhance their chemistry higher than a typical duo, then Harrison could enhance even additional.
Harrison’s first season was full of huge expectations, which he didn’t totally stay as much as. Luckily, his goal charge was excessive, and his goal competitors stays restricted. He ought to end among the many top-20 broad receivers in targets once more, and he wants to enhance his chemistry with Kyler Murray so his fantasy worth can be among the many top-20 broad receivers.
QB J.J. McCarthy, Minnesota Vikings (ADP: 14.04)
J.J. McCarthy spent three years as a quarterback at Michigan, initially as a backup to Cade McNamara, however then he beat out McNamara for the beginning job in 2022. He by no means was a high-volume quarterback on account of Michigan’s run-first offense and continuously taking part in with a lead, however he was nice on a per-play foundation. He was within the ninetieth percentile or higher in every scenario. He improved considerably from his first yr as a starter to his second. His dropbacks per recreation decreased, however his stats nonetheless elevated due to a a lot greater accuracy charge.
McCarthy equally by no means ran the ball too typically himself, however he had a really excessive charge of gaining not less than 15 yards or a primary down. His pace and athleticism are each above common for an NFL quarterback.
His success at Michigan led the Minnesota Vikings to pick out McCarthy with the tenth decide of the 2024 NFL Draft after Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Drake Maye and Michael Penix Jr. however simply earlier than Bo Nix. The Vikings had moved on from Kirk Cousins at quarterback and signed Sam Darnold, who was initially the starter, however the common assumption was that McCarthy would take over both earlier than Week 1 or not lengthy after. However, McCarthy tore his meniscus. He had surgical procedure to restore it and missed his complete rookie yr.
While Darnold performed nicely for the Vikings, Minnesota opted to not re-sign him and persist with McCarthy as its starter for the 2025 season. From all studies, McCarthy is wanting wholesome and must be totally able to go for the season.
McCarthy joins the Minnesota Vikings offense led by Kevin O’Connell. His offenses have been nice for quarterbacks. The Vikings usually run an average-to-high variety of performs and are persistently passing the ball at a excessive charge. Sam Darnold was a top-10 fantasy quarterback final season, Kirk Cousins was in 2022, and in 2023, he was high 10 in factors per recreation. In 2023, after Cousins’ harm, Dobbs was a top-12 fantasy quarterback in three of 4 video games he performed 100% of his group’s offensive snaps, whereas Nick Mullens was a top-14 fantasy quarterback when he performed 100% of the snaps. Both Dobbs and Mullens had weeks as a top-five fantasy quarterback.
McCarthy can be surrounded by a robust receiving group in Minnesota, with Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison at broad receiver, T.J. Hockenson at tight finish and Aaron Jones Sr. at operating again. The Jefferson and Hockenson duo has been round for a number of seasons and is a part of the explanation the Vikings quarterbacks at all times carry out higher in fantasy than they do in real-life quarterback rankings. Even if McCarthy struggles like most quarterbacks do of their first yr, the supporting forged and training workers must be sufficient to make McCarthy a top-24 fantasy quarterback. There is an opportunity McCarthy performs higher than previous Vikings quarterbacks, through which he could possibly be a top-eight choice.
The Vikings had a mean offensive line in go safety final season, however there may be purpose to imagine they are going to be significantly better this season. Brian O’Neill is the one returning full-time starter, and he was the most effective pass-protecting proper tackles final season. Christian Darrisaw had emerged as the most effective younger left tackles within the league however missed half the yr on account of harm. The inside of the road wasn’t nice, main the Vikings so as to add Donovan Jackson within the first spherical of the draft along with free brokers Ryan Kelly and Will Fries from the Indianapolis Colts. All of them must be not less than minor upgrades over the 2024 starters.
Every quarterback who’s of their first yr as a starter with minimal speeding upside is a danger for fantasy soccer, however the teaching workers and surrounding forged in Minnesota put J.J. McCarthy in a greater place to succeed than practically all different first-year beginning quarterbacks of current seasons. McCarthy ought to already be thought of a starter in superflex leagues and is a good high-upside choice as a backup in single-quarterback leagues.
QB Caleb Williams, Chicago Bears (ADP: 10.09)
Caleb Williams was the primary general decide of the 2024 NFL draft, so he changed Justin Fields because the Chicago Bears‘ beginning quarterback. Williams was drafted in fantasy drafts to be a borderline fantasy starter, which is extraordinary for rookie quarterbacks except there may be large speeding upside. For Williams, the distinction was the scenario. The Bears had been a 7-10 group with a near-even level differential somewhat than the worst group within the league – Williams was gifted, the Bears already had D.J. Moore, and so they added Keenan Allen and Rome Odunze.
Unfortunately, Williams received off to a tough begin. He accomplished lower than half of his passes in Week 1 with a 50.2 passing grade and completed as QB33 that week. Week 2 wasn’t significantly better, as he completed with barely higher cumulative stats however a 42.7 passing grade.
Williams might solely go up from there, as there have been some flashes of an incredible quarterback all through the season. He achieved a PFF passing grade between 75.0 and 83.0 in 4 house video games, largely within the second half of the season. He ended up as QB16 on the season, which wasn’t far off from the place he was drafted, however he was twenty second in factors per recreation. He had 5 video games as a top-six fantasy quarterback, which largely coincided with the video games the place he graded nicely, however he was outdoors of the top-18 fantasy quarterbacks in over half of his video games, making it unimaginable to know when to begin Williams in single-quarterback leagues.
Adding Ben Johnson as head coach must be a major optimistic, because the Lions’ offense has been high-scoring for a number of years. Jared Goff has been an excellent, however not nice, quarterback in line with PFF’s passing grade, and but his efficiency in Johnson’s system final season led to Goff being a top-seven fantasy quarterback. Ideally, Williams could be a higher quarterback than Goff and have the identical rewards from a fantasy perspective.
Johnson’s passing assault has usually concerned throwing shorter passes which are simpler to finish, which ought to typically assist William’s numbers. However, his offenses have additionally been extra run-heavy. It’s unclear if that would be the case in Chicago as a result of Johnson’s Lions invested closely of their high two operating backs, whereas Chicago hasn’t made any adjustments on the place. Williams was among the many leaders in dropbacks per recreation final season, and that would doubtlessly lower this season. Johnson’s offenses additionally didn’t result in many designed speeding makes an attempt by his quarterback. Part of that could possibly be due to Goff, but it surely is also Johnson’s choice, which might imply fewer speeding makes an attempt by Williams.
While the Ben Johnson addition as head coach is a giant purpose for optimism surrounding Williams, the Bears adopted up that addition with a number of extra key gamers to the offense, which also needs to assist Williams.
The Bears determined to not re-sign Keenan Allen however as a substitute introduced in Luther Burden III with an early second-round decide. They additionally added tight finish Colston Loveland within the first spherical. D.J. Moore has performed nicely all through his profession, and Rome Odunze was a top-10 decide in 2024 and can ideally enhance in his second season. This group of 4 receivers has the potential to be the very best four-person receiving group within the league, however thus far, solely one of many 4 gamers has labored out within the NFL. While the potential for this unit is sky-high, there’s a variety of potentialities for the way this unit performs this season.
Williams is a good choice for these in single-quarterback leagues who wish to wait on quarterbacks. Anyone drafting Williams will want another choice, simply in case the entire new shifting elements on offense want a while to work out. Williams has one of many clearest paths to be a top-five fantasy quarterback amongst these ranked outdoors of the highest 10.
RB Braelon Allen, New York Jets (ADP: 19.09)
Braelon Allen joined the New York Jets as a fourth-round decide from the 2024 NFL Draft. The Jets’ main backup to Breece Hall in 2023 was Dalvin Cook, however the Jets didn’t find yourself re-signing Cook. Hall was coping with a quadriceps harm early within the yr, permitting Allen to run seven occasions for 33 yards and a landing in Week 2 and 11 occasions for 55 yards in Week 3.
His taking part in time fluctuated all year long, totaling two to seven carries most weeks. Allen began in Week 14 when Hall was out on account of a knee harm. He performed 54.4% of New York’s offensive snaps that recreation, whereas his excessive in different weeks was 36.5%. He ran 11 occasions for 43 yards and caught 4 passes for 38 yards, whereas fifth-round rookie Isaiah Davis was additionally given a chance to shine.
Allen averaged a low 3.6 yards per carry, however he graded nicely due to his wonderful play in short-yardage conditions. Allen ran the ball 16 occasions when the Jets wanted two yards or much less for a primary down, and he transformed 14 of them. He averaged 3.3 yards per stick with it these runs, whereas the league common was 3.2. His 90.0 speeding grade on these runs was the very best amongst operating backs.
The Jets didn’t make any adjustments to their backfield for 2025, as Hall and Davis had been Allen’s main sources of competitors. The group additionally added Justin Fields at quarterback, and he can be operating the ball much more than Aaron Rodgers. This might additionally embrace short-yardage conditions. The Jets voted to maintain the tush push, so there’s a probability Fields, particularly, might take these one-yard carries, although Allen was very profitable at them.
Allen is without doubt one of the greatest operating backs within the league at 6-foot-1 and 235 kilos. Most operating backs of that dimension aren’t used considerably in passing conditions. Derrick Henry, Najee Harris, Gus Edwards, D’Onta Foreman and James Conner have not often been utilized in passing conditions. Henry and Conner have been capable of flip into constant fantasy starters regardless of this, however Allen would want to not less than double his speeding makes an attempt per recreation with the intention to attain their stage.
The Jets employed Aaron Glenn as head coach and Tanner Engstrand as offensive coordinator from the Detroit Lions. In current years, the Detroit Lions have used both Jamaal Williams or David Montgomery on early downs and D’Andre Swift or Jahmyr Gibbs on passing downs. Allen could possibly be nicely fitted to that early-down position, as he is a much bigger again than both Williams or Montgomery. The two had been used to transform first downs, put on down the protection and, most significantly, rating touchdowns.
The operating again on this position has completed within the high 20 in fantasy factors per recreation every of the final three seasons. A couple of issues have to go proper to ensure that Allen to succeed in that top-20 vary. Engstrand wants to make use of the identical operating again rotation, and Fields can’t be used because the runner in short-yardage conditions.
The Jets additionally want their offensive line to play near the Lions’ stage. Detroit has ranked among the many high 10 in run-blocking grade every of the final three seasons, whereas the Jets ranked twelfth final season. The Jets moved on from veteran tackles Tyron Smith and Morgan Moses for 2 first-round picks in Olu Fashanu and Armand Membou. The complete line has a really excessive optimistic grade charge, which is usually good for breaking lengthy runs. They have combined outcomes in the case of negatively blocked runs. However, Allen stood out in how nicely he performed on non-perfectly blocked runs with 3.4 yards per carry. Montgomery additionally had 3.4 yards per stick with it non-perfectly blocked runs, however Montgomery was higher on the positively blocked runs. If Allen can keep away from extra tackles as soon as the road offers him these clear blocks, that would make a giant distinction to his fantasy manufacturing.
The purpose is for Allen to be the subsequent David Montgomery. The teaching workers wants to make use of him in that position, the offense must play nicely sufficient for Allen to attain sufficient factors, and Justin Fields can’t be used on the tush push. While that may be a lot, there may be equally rather a lot for some other late-round operating again, and this one doesn’t require an harm to a starter.
RB Trey Benson, Arizona Cardinals (ADP: 16.09)
Trey Benson was a third-round decide by the Arizona Cardinals within the 2024 NFL Draft. It was apparent that Benson can be James Conner‘s backup in his rookie season after Conner set career-highs in yards per carry and speeding yards per recreation in 2023. Conner can also be among the many older operating backs within the NFL with over 1,000 profession carries, so Benson gave the impression to be the Cardinals’ operating again of the longer term. Conner had additionally missed a minimal of two video games each season, which made it appear doubtless that Benson would see not less than a couple of begins because the lead operating again as a rookie. The risk of a Conner harm made Benson one of many high handcuff choices in redraft leagues final season.
Conner missed the season’s final recreation, however sadly, Benson suffered an ankle harm in Week 15, inflicting him to overlook the final two video games of the season. That, sadly, meant he missed his one alternative to begin.
Benson performed anyplace from two to 22 snaps every week. He ran the ball 5 occasions or fewer in most of his video games. The 4 exceptions had been all 20-point blowouts, with three within the Cardinals‘ favor. Benson ran eight to 11 occasions in these video games. Benson didn’t grade all that nice as a runner, largely thanks to 1 fumble. He had stable first-down and 10-plus-yard carry charges. It’s exhausting to take an excessive amount of away from Benson’s stats, contemplating a excessive share of them got here within the fourth quarter when video games had been out of attain.
Benson was barely used as a receiver, however he caught all six of his targets, and half resulted in first downs.
Benson stays in a tough spot with the Cardinals this season. Arizona saved an an identical backfield to final season, together with bringing again the practice-squad operating backs who would get elevated throughout an harm. Often, if a operating again was ready within the wings, they might play in no matter scenario the primary operating again was weakest at. However, Conner performed all the things however third downs, and Emari Demercado performed on third downs. This meant Conner had these performs to relaxation and didn’t have to get rotated out as typically on early downs.
Benson tended to get used to extra in short-yardage conditions, although he and Conner are very related in dimension. Conner was within the final season of his contract, however in late November, Conner signed a two-year extension. That means Conner is beneath contract this season with little to no probability he might get traded. The Cardinals can comfortably transfer on from Conner after the season in the event that they wish to, however his price ticket for 2026 is cheap sufficient in the event that they wish to preserve him.
This means Benson is in the very same spot as he was final yr. He is Conner’s handcuff, and both wants Conner’s play to say no or for him to get injured for Benson to play vital snaps. Given Conner’s harm historical past, it’s extra doubtless Benson will see begins this season in comparison with different backup operating backs. We can count on Benson to totally take Conner’s position if he’s injured.
