A social media ballot revealed placing outcomes, with 82% of individuals favouring unlawful Mexican immigrants over authorized Indian immigrants to the United States, whereas solely 18% supported the latter. The ballot, hosted on X (previously Twitter), has ignited widespread debate on-line for its controversial framing of the query: “Illegal Mexicans” vs. “Legal Indians” as immigrants to the US.
The ballot’s final result drew widespread criticism for its overtly racist undertones. Users flocked to the feedback part, many condemning the ballot itself and the preferences it highlighted. One consumer wrote, “How is that this even a query? Pitting one group towards one other is disgusting.” Another added, “The outcomes present the deep-seated biases that also plague American society.”
Others, nonetheless, used the ballot to justify their immigration priorities, citing cultural familiarity and historic ties with Mexico as causes for his or her votes. “Mexicans have all the time been a part of our workforce and neighborhood. Indians are simply taking high-skilled jobs,” claimed a consumer, echoing a long-standing stereotype about immigrant labour within the US.
The divisive ballot additionally sparked broader conversations about systemic racism and the inherent biases within the US immigration system. “This is a transparent indication that immigration debates aren’t about legality; they’re about race and ethnicity,” famous a critic on X.
Take a have a look at the publish:
The publish was additional reshared on Reddit, amplifying the controversy. It was accompanied by the caption, “At the top of the day it is about seems and aesthetics. In the fashionable day Indian tradition, principally males, pay 0 consideration to seems. We are programmed for survival. Unlike males of different international locations the place bodily look is a crucial half. Hopefully issues would enhance in present generations.”
Reacting to the publish, a consumer wrote, “Um.. what? You wish to change your seems due to some racists?”
Another argued, “They need Mexicans as a result of Mexicans do the bodily work for them, however the authorized educated Indians are in prime positions.”
This debate comes towards the backdrop of rising concern over immigration on the US-Mexico border. According to the BBC, since January 2021, when President Joe Biden took workplace, there have been over 10 million encounters with migrants trying to enter the US Of these, round 8 million have been intercepted on the southwest border with Mexico.
Recent figures reveal that within the present monetary yr (October 2023–September 2024), Mexicans accounted for the most important group of people encountered on the southern border, with 617,770 crossings. Venezuelans adopted with practically 250,000 crossings, and Guatemalans with roughly 200,000. The overwhelming majority of these trying to cross the US southern border are residents of neighbouring American international locations, additional complicating the immigration discourse.
Also learn: US millionaire who introduced his personal meals to India now promotes Indian delicacies: ‘Floating oil tikkas’